LowPowerLab Forum

Hardware support => Moteino => Topic started by: K1JOS on June 14, 2014, 11:06:48 PM

Title: RFM69HW and Inconsistent ACK reply [SOLVED]
Post by: K1JOS on June 14, 2014, 11:06:48 PM
I have my 2 Moteino RFM69HW next to each other and I am just running the RFM examples struct_send and struct_receive.  With the Serial Monitor on the struct_receive Moteino, I find that the Pinging every third pass only gets an occasional ACK.  Usually I see the 4-5 ACK...nothing for every ACK...ok!

Is this normal?



[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=426900 temp=91.23 - ACK sent. Pinging node 99 - ACK...ok!
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=427200 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=427500 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=428400 temp=91.23 - ACK sent. Pinging node 99 - ACK...nothing
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-90] nodeId=99 uptime=429000 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=429300 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=429600 temp=91.23 - ACK sent. Pinging node 99 - ACK...nothing
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-92] nodeId=99 uptime=430800 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=431100 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=431400 temp=91.23 - ACK sent. Pinging node 99 - ACK...nothing
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=431700 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=432300 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-93] nodeId=99 uptime=433500 temp=91.23 - ACK sent. Pinging node 99 - ACK...ok!
[99]  [RX_RSSI:-91] nodeId=99 uptime=434100 temp=91.23 - ACK sent.

Title: Re: RFM69HW and Inconsistent ACK reply
Post by: edesio on June 15, 2014, 10:20:37 PM
Hi!

Check the antennas. The signal level (-91) is too low for reliable connection.
Title: Re: RFM69HW and Inconsistent ACK reply
Post by: K1JOS on June 15, 2014, 10:58:35 PM
Hi,

That's a great point.  I had some other RFM69 sketches running and they showed an RSSI of -29 not -91.  I dont know why its showing that low power... I will check. 

thanks
jerry
Title: Re: RFM69HW and Inconsistent ACK reply
Post by: Felix on June 16, 2014, 08:28:23 AM
edesio has a good point. Also check your HW settings, and make sure you got the latest lib code from github.
Check this thread as well: https://lowpowerlab.com/forum/index.php/topic,520.0.html
Title: Re: RFM69HW and Inconsistent ACK reply
Post by: K1JOS on June 16, 2014, 01:45:54 PM
Yes, I did not have high power enable on either.  I thought that for testing with the two Moteino antenna's being inches from each other all would be OK.  After enabling high power I am getting -28dB and 100% ACK.

Is the low power mode of the RFM69HW so much lower output than the regular output of a RFM69?
Title: Re: RFM69HW and Inconsistent ACK reply
Post by: Felix on June 16, 2014, 03:16:49 PM
No, if you don't tell it it's a HW it will not work correctly. It's telling it to use a certain amplifier path which is not present in the W.